Skip to main content

Educational tool only. All groups exist on a spectrum of control. Individual experiences vary. Based on publicly available reports, ex-member accounts, court records, and expert analyses — not medical or legal advice.

CLCI Hub

Methodology

How CLCI scores are built, weighed, contested, and revised. These pages document the editorial and analytic infrastructure behind every group profile so readers, researchers, and the organisations themselves can audit our reasoning.

CLCI Hub publishes a numeric score from 0 to 40 for each group, broken into five spectrum bands from Minimal documented control through Destructive / Extreme. That number is the easy part. The harder, more important part is what sits behind it: the sources, the editorial standards, the band thresholds, the way we handle contested evidence and living people, the conditions under which a score changes, and what we will not change a score for. These methodology pages cover that machinery in detail.

If you are a survivor, family member, or general reader, you do not need to read every page here. The BITE model page explains what each axis measures; the confidence levels page explains what the High/Medium/Low badges mean. Those two are enough to read a group profile critically. The other four pages exist for researchers, journalists, named organisations, and anyone who wants to challenge a specific rating on substantive grounds.

The methodology pages

How the methodology relates to the rest of the site

The methodology pages are companion documents to a small set of editorial policies that govern publication itself. The Editorial Policy explains what we will and will not publish and why. The Source Policy is the canonical source-tier document — the Source Hierarchy page here covers the same ground in slightly more detail and includes the contested-evidence handling. The Corrections page is the intake route for factual errors; the Right of Reply page is the intake route for organisational responses.

How the methodology evolves

These pages are living documents. When we tighten a definition, change a band threshold, add a new source category, or revise an editorial standard, the change is logged in the Transparency Report and reflected in the relevant methodology page's last-reviewed date. Earlier methodology versions are recoverable from the public GitHub history.

We invite scrutiny. If you find a methodology page that contradicts how a specific profile was actually scored, or a profile that was scored in a way the methodology does not authorise, that is a meaningful inconsistency — please flag it via the Corrections page. The methodology is intended to be honest about what it can and cannot do.

This site is educational and not legal, medical, or clinical advice. See the Legal Disclaimer for the full statement.