Skip to main content

Educational tool only. All groups exist on a spectrum of control. Individual experiences vary. Based on publicly available reports, ex-member accounts, court records, and expert analyses — not medical or legal advice.

CLCI Hub

Reforms and Score Reduction

CLCI scores are not fixed. Where a group implements substantive, documented, sustained reform of the practices that produced its score, the score can be revised downward. This page documents what reform we recognise, what evidence we expect, and what would not qualify.

The principle

CLCI rates documented conduct against the BITE model. If documented conduct changes — and the change is sustained, visible, and verifiable — the rating should change. We do not treat a high-control history as a permanent verdict. Holding a group's past score against it after substantive reform would be both unfair and methodologically incoherent.

What we count as reform

What does not, on its own, qualify

Sustained reform

We look for sustained reform — typically multiple years of consistent practice — before making material score reductions. Single events (one policy revision, one new leader) are recorded in the changelog but do not automatically reduce the score. The asymmetry is deliberate: scores changed too readily would become unreliable, and the burden of evidence for change should mirror the burden of evidence used to establish the score in the first place.

How to submit reform evidence

Use the scoring appeals process. We ask for: a clear statement of what has changed, the documented evidence for the change (sources, dates, formal policies), and any external verification available. We do not require commercial consideration, advertising agreements, or promotional arrangements; we will not give them weight if offered.

What appears on the profile when a score is reduced

The group's changeLog[] records the date, the previous score, the new score, and the documented basis for the revision. The profile retains a history of the prior practices — reform is recorded, not erased — but the headline score reflects the current state. See /updates/scores for recent score revisions across the catalogue.

Related