Skip to main content

Educational tool only. All groups exist on a spectrum of control. Individual experiences vary. Based on publicly available reports, ex-member accounts, court records, and expert analyses — not medical or legal advice.

CLCI Hub

Scoring Appeals

What evidence can change a CLCI score, what evidence cannot, how branches and time periods are handled, how reforms are credited, and what makes a substantive appeal as opposed to a disagreement.

Anyone may ask us to reconsider a score: a named organisation, a current member, a former member, a researcher, a journalist, a family member, a member of the public who has read more on the group than we have. The Corrections page is the intake route. This page explains what a substantive scoring appeal looks like and how we process it.

The distinction between factual correction and scoring appeal

A factual correction targets a specific assertion (a founding date, a name spelling, a court-case outcome, a regional presence). Factual corrections move through the Corrections workflow and are typically processed within two weeks where the evidence supports the change. They rarely move the score itself unless the corrected fact undermines a BITE-axis claim.

A scoring appeal asks us to reweight one or more BITE axes, change the Modifier, or move the confidence rating. Appeals require a substantive comparative case, not a single source, because each axis is calibrated against the comparator spread of other groups in the dataset. We process appeals through additional editorial review and they typically take longer.

What evidence can change a score

What evidence cannot change a score

How branches and time periods are handled

Many of the most common scoring disputes turn on which entity is being scored. A globally diverse movement may have moderate-control practice in most branches and high-control practice in one specific branch. A reforming organisation may have a markedly different operational pattern today than in the 1970s. CLCI Hub addresses this with deliberate entity-level granularity.

If you believe a single profile is conflating two entities that should be scored separately, that is a substantive structural appeal and we welcome it. Useful supporting material includes evidence of distinct leadership, distinct doctrinal emphasis, distinct geographic reach, and distinct operational practice across the entities you want separated.

How reforms are credited

Reform credit is the most editorially demanding scoring change. The operational risk is twofold: granting reform credit on the basis of leadership statements that have not yet been operationalised, and refusing reform credit for genuine structural change because the historical record is still louder than the present.

Our standard for reform credit:

Where reform credit is applied, the historical record is preserved in the timeline and the change is logged in the public changelog. The new score reflects current practice; the historical pattern remains documented.

How to submit a substantive appeal

Use the Corrections intake. A substantive scoring appeal helps us most when it includes:

  1. The profile slug or URL.
  2. The specific BITE axis or Modifier you believe is mis-scored, and the direction (up or down) you believe the rating should move.
  3. Specific evidence supporting your view — court records, government reports, peer-reviewed work, established journalism, named on-the-record ex-member testimony.
  4. A comparison against at least two comparator profiles in the dataset showing why the axis or Modifier is out of line with comparable groups.
  5. Acknowledgement of any contrary evidence you are aware of and your view on why the supporting evidence outweighs it.
  6. Your role and relationship to the matter (optional, but helpful for context).

Appeals from named organisations are processed through the same workflow and held to the same evidentiary standard as appeals from any other party. We do not give organisations editorial veto over their own scores, and we do not give critics editorial veto either. Both are welcome to make their substantive case.

What an appeal will not yield

See also Corrections · Right of Reply · Source Hierarchy · Score Updates