Skip to main content

Educational tool only. All groups exist on a spectrum of control. Individual experiences vary. Based on publicly available reports, ex-member accounts, court records, and expert analyses — not medical or legal advice.

CLCI Hub

Confidence Levels

Every group profile on CLCI Hub carries a confidence rating — High, Medium, or Low — alongside its numeric score. The confidence rating reports how strong the underlying evidence is. This page explains what each tier means and what readers should infer from it.

Why confidence matters as much as the score

A score of 32 with Low confidence is meaningfully different from a score of 32 with High confidence. The first says “based on currently available public material, this group's operational pattern appears to fit the destructive-control band, but the evidence is thin and a substantive new primary source could move the score in either direction.” The second says “based on multiple corroborating court records, peer-reviewed work, and substantial journalistic investigation, this group's pattern is documented to fit the destructive-control band; a single new source is unlikely to materially change the rating.”

Confidence is a separate dimension because it answers a separate question: not how controlling is the operation but how well do we know what the operation actually does. Some of the most controlling groups in the world are also the most documented (the public-record trail is substantial); some are the least (small, closed, or jurisdictionally protected). The score reports the rating; the confidence reports the evidence base.

High confidence

High confidence applies where the public record contains multiple substantial primary sources plus corroborating secondary work. A typical High-confidence profile carries:

High confidence does not require every BITE-axis claim to be court-attested. It requires that the overall operational pattern is sufficiently documented across multiple independent sources that a new single source is unlikely to materially shift the rating. The Church of Scientology, Jehovah's Witnesses, FLDS, NXIVM, and Aum Shinrikyo are illustrative examples of High confidence: court findings, government investigations, academic studies, and substantial investigative reporting all exist in the public record.

Medium confidence

Medium confidence applies where credible secondary work documents the operational pattern but the primary-source record is incomplete or partially contested. A typical Medium-confidence profile carries:

Medium confidence is the modal rating across the dataset. It honestly reflects the state of public-record evidence for many high-control groups: there is enough credible secondary documentation to score the operational pattern, but not enough primary-source weight to call the rating settled.

Low confidence

Low confidence applies where the available evidence is fragmentary, anecdotal, single-source, or actively contested. A typical Low-confidence profile carries:

Low-confidence ratings are explicitly provisional. They represent our current best summary of the documented pattern given the evidence we have been able to surface. A substantive new primary source — a court filing, a government inquiry, a major investigative piece — can move a Low-confidence rating up or down significantly. We mark Low-confidence profiles on the header and invite correction submissions from anyone with access to additional public-record material.

What confidence is not

How confidence changes over time

Confidence ratings move as the public-record trail grows or thins. New court proceedings, government inquiries, peer-reviewed studies, or major investigative pieces can move a profile from Medium to High. Retractions, successful appeals, or successful defamation defences by the organisation can move it the other direction. Where a profile has been reassessed, the confidence change is logged in the public changelog alongside the date and the source that drove the reassessment. See Score Updates for the changelog mechanics.

What readers should do with the confidence rating

Read confidence first, then score. If a profile is High-confidence and Extreme band, the published material on coercive control is unusually substantial and a sceptical reader can verify the core claims via the linked sources. If a profile is Low-confidence and Moderate band, the rating should be treated as a starting hypothesis for further reading rather than as a settled summary.

Where confidence is Low, we particularly welcome additional sources from people who have direct knowledge — current or former members, journalists who have reported on the group, academics who have studied it. The Corrections route is the standard intake.

See also The BITE Model · Source Hierarchy · Scoring Appeals